Cybercrime
,
Fraud Management & Cybercrime
,
Geo Focus: The United Kingdom
Amendment to Computer Misuse Act Fails During Bloc Vote
A proposed amendment to British anti-hacking law that would have provided a legal shield to white hat hackers failed Wednesday in the House of Lords.
See Also: Strengthening Your Security Program With Open API
U.K. lawmakers considering legislation put forward by the Labour government modifying the country’s data regulatory framework decided not to support an amendment creating new legal defenses against charges under the Computer Misuse Act.
The amendment, put forward by Conservative life peer Chris Holmes, failed during a bloc vote on amendments to the Data Use and Access Bill.
Under the Computer Misuse Act, access to a computer system without adequate consent from the system owner is illegal, heightening the legal risk of activities such as security research. The Holmes amendment would have created new defenses to CMA charges including that unauthorized access to a computer would not be illegal so long as “the person’s actions were necessary for the detection or prevention of crime,” or “were justified as being in the public interest.”
A recent study by CyberUp Campaign, a coalition lobbying the government to introduce the CMA updates, asserted that most British security experts believe the Computer Misuse Act poses barriers to threat intelligence and security vulnerability research.
“The statutory defense drafted in consultation with industry and legal experts would protect legitimate cybersecurity professionals, strengthen U.K. cyber defenses, and reinforce its place as a cybersecurity leader,” said Andrew Jones, strategy director The Cyber Scheme Limited, which offers cybersecurity certifications.
The Labour government has not fully ruled out the possibility of the CMA update, with the Minister for Security Dan Jarvis recently stating that updating of the law is a priority.