Account Takeover Fraud
,
Fraud Management & Cybercrime
A Look Back at 3 Key Identity Fraud Trends in 2025

Fraudsters stick to the basics, because the basics work. Synthetic identities, fake accounts and tried-and-tested account takeovers still work, even in an age of artificial intelligence-related threats. Deepfakes and other AI threats may dominate the discourse, but scammers are happy to keep on stealing the old-fashioned way.
See Also: Going Beyond the Copilot Pilot – A CISO’s Perspective
Fraud teams are rushing to build AI-powered defenses and detection systems for tomorrow’s threats, while fraudsters find success with yesterday’s playbook. Enterprises are not ignoring identity fraud – but are definitely sidelining it. When executive attention and security budgets tilt heavily toward emerging AI threats, the unglamorous work of strengthening identity verification, monitoring account behavior and closing authentication gaps often gets deferred.
Here are three identity fraud trends that tell the story of the growing crisis in 2025.
Synthetic Identity Fraud
Auto lenders emerged as a primary target for synthetic IDs. Why bother with $300 in credit card fraud when a fake ID can unlock an auto loan worth $50,000? The sector lost $2.1 billion to entirely made-up people in 2024, according to a report by credit rating agency TransUnion.
The method is simple: Blend real Social Security numbers – usually belonging to children, the elderly or people who don’t check their credit – with fake names, addresses and birthdates. More than 16,000 data breaches over the past five years have flooded criminal marketplaces with stolen credentials, while fraud-as-a-service models flourishing on platforms like Telegram make identity fabrication more accessible than ever.
Account Takeover Fraud
Fraudsters are no longer asking for your money. They are simply taking it by taking control over accounts slowly and waiting for the right moment to drain funds. In 2025, cybercriminals preferred slipping into your digital avatar and transferring money rather than luring victims into making authorized transactions.
Account takeover fraud is all about mimicking legitimate behavior, and fraudsters are getting better at it. The FBI reported that between January and October, it received more than 5,100 complaints involving ATO scams impersonating bank support teams. Total losses amounted to $262 million.
These scams usually go like this: A victim gets a call from someone pretending to be from the bank’s fraud department. They sound helpful. They warn of suspicious activity. The victims are then lured to give up control of their accounts.
It’s not just a U.S. problem. Globally, ATO fraud cost businesses nearly $13 billion in 2023 – up from $11 billion in 2022. And it’s not slowing down. The first half of 2025 experienced an ATO volume spike of 21% compared to the same period the year before.
A TransUnion study found that fraud now eats up 7.7% of annual revenue equivalent for companies worldwide. A good chunk of that comes straight from ATOs. A recent Entrust report paints an equally grim picture. In payments, 82% of fraud attempts strike during authentication, and 55% hit after onboarding.
New Account Fraud
New account fraud remains a persistent threat, with fraudsters exploiting the onboarding process to create illegitimate accounts for financial gain. According to Entrust, industries offering upfront incentives are especially vulnerable to new account fraud. Crypto platforms experienced 67% of their fraud attempts during account creation.
Fraudulent documents are the primary enabler of new account fraud. Entrust found that national ID cards accounted for nearly half of all fraudulent document submissions globally in 2025, followed by driver’s licenses at 25% and passports at 19%.
The nature of document fraud has shifted toward digital methods. Physical counterfeits still represent 47% of attempts but digital forgeries surged to 35%. Generative AI has accelerated this trend, with fraudsters creating replicas using open-source models and simple prompts.
Half of document fraud attempts targeting crypto companies are now digital forgeries. Fraudsters increasingly pair fraudulent documents with biometric spoofing.
